Skip links

4505 South Harding Street: Strategic Acquisition & Profitable Disposition

4505 South Harding Street: Strategic Acquisition & Profitable Disposition

DEAL HIGHLIGHTS

42% reduction asking price.

Record sale for price per acre for IOSin the Indianapolis MSA.

Client Profile

Harding Street, Inc. is a well-established real estate investment firm specializing in value-add opportunities. Their strategic approach focuses on identifying underutilized properties, enhancing their market potential, and optimizing returns through repositioning and redevelopment.

Harding Street, Inc. & Allies Partnership

Allies Commercial Realty partnered with Harding Street, Inc. to assist in the acquisition, repositioning, and eventual disposition of 4505 South Harding Street, an underutilized site with significant challenges. Our expertise in negotiation, zoning strategy, and market positioning allowed our client to transform a distressed property into a lucrative investment.

Opportunity and Challenge

The 4505 South Harding Street site was a former motel that had been abandoned for some time, leading to concerns related to property maintenance, security, and unauthorized use. The site required significant remediation and repositioning to restore its value and attract the right buyer. Key challenges included:

  • City-mandated demolition order due to unsafe conditions.
  • Asbestos contamination, requiring additional remediation costs.
  • Non-ideal zoning (MU-1 Mixed-Use), limiting its marketability.
  • Floodplain designation, complicating redevelopment options.

Despite these obstacles, the owner was motivated to sell but sought to maximize the sale price. Given the complexity of the site, a buyer would need both the capital and expertise to navigate the environmental and zoning restrictions while recognizing the property’s long-term value. Our goal was to strategically position the property to attract competitive offers while ensuring our client achieved a strong return on their investment.

DEAL HIGHLIGHTS

42% reduction asking price.

Record sale for price per acre for IOSin the Indianapolis MSA.

Analysis

After conducting an in-depth evaluation of the property and market conditions, we determined that the highest and best use would be truck and trailer parking or an industrial redevelopment, which required a rezoning to I-3 Heavy Industrial or C-7 Heavy Commercial. However, due to the site’s location in a floodplain, achieving the necessary rezoning was a significant challenge. The environmental reports confirmed a clean bill of health, but the demolition process required additional due diligence due to asbestos contamination. Given these factors, we knew the property had strong market potential but needed to be positioned effectively to overcome buyer hesitations.

Meet the Brokers Behind this Success Story

4505 South Harding Street, Indianapolis, IN 46217

Our Success Story

Strategic Acquisition

  • The property owner initially sought $1.25 million, but through expert negotiations, Allies Commercial Realty secured the site for $875,000—a significant price reduction.
  • Harding Street, Inc. completed demolition and environmental remediation, bringing their total investment to approximately $1.5 million.

 

Market Positioning & Disposition

  • Despite zoning challenges, we listed the property for lease at $15,000/month, a strategic move to attract interest from potential buyers.
  • The approach generated multiple offers, starting at $1.7 million and increasing to $2.5 million.
  • Final Sale: A global organization ultimately purchased the property for $3 million, following strategic negotiations that maximized the sale price.
  • Total Net Proceeds: After commissions and closing costs, Harding Street, Inc. netted $2.73 million, allowing them to roll the proceeds into a 1031 exchange to defer capital gains taxes and reinvest in new opportunities.

 

Results

  • Expert Negotiation: Acquired the property at a 42% discount, securing favorable terms for our client.
  • Value-Add Strategy: Positioned the property effectively despite zoning restrictions, maximizing buyer interest.
  • Profitable Disposition: Achieved a final sale price of $3 million, exceeding initial market expectations.
  • 1031 Exchange Optimization: Enabled the client to reinvest tax-free, furthering their investment growth.

Conclusion

Allies Commercial Realty’s strategic market positioning, expert negotiation, and deep understanding of zoning and redevelopment allowed Harding Street, Inc. to transform a distressed property into a highly profitable investment. This project highlights our ability to navigate complex real estate challenges, secure favorable acquisition terms, and maximize exit strategies for our clients.

Ready to Write Your Own Success Story?
Let’s explore how we can help you achieve your commercial real estate goals.

Working with Allies Commercial Realty was a great experience from start to finish. Their team is extremely knowledgeable and professional. They helped us navigate tough challenges and made the process run smoothly. From acquisition to disposition, they were always one step ahead, finding creative solutions and keeping things on track. We have closed on multiple properties through them. In terms of selling, we sold some with a great profit and bought others at very decent price just because of Adam and his team and their great work. We couldn’t have asked for a better partner and look forward to continuing to work with them!

Malkiat Singh

Dana Mannix

In Other Case Studies

1349 Sunday Drive: Maximizing Value in Investment Sale and Asset Disposition

John Guy, owner of a 13,356 SF office-industrial building in Indianapolis's south submarket, faced the decision to sell his specialized property.

Read More

RAWAAL Properties LLC: Strategic Acquisition and Maximizing Asset Value Through Expert Leasing

RAWAAL Properties LLC is a forward-thinking investment firm specializing in commercial real estate

Read More

Dana Mannix Gymnastics Center: Strategic Expansion and Lease Negotiation in a Rising Industrial Market

Dana Mannix Gymnastics Center is a premier gymnastics facility dedicated to providing high-quality

Read More

Cookies improve your browsing experience, deliver tailored ads or content, and assess our website traffic. If you click 'Accept All’ you are giving your consent for us to utilize cookies. Check our cookies policy here.