Collision Restoration LLC: Strategic Expansion & Market Growth

DEAL HIGHLIGHTS
Secured a long term lease with fixed renewal options across the portfolio.
Negotiated turn-key tenant improvement package across all locations.
Client Profile
Collision Restoration LLC, founded by Aaron Colburn, is a growing auto collision repair business serving the North Indianapolis and Central Indiana market. With years of experience in the auto dealership collision repair industry, Aaron decided to venture out on his own, establishing Collision Restoration LLC with a vision of expanding across multiple locations.
Collision Restoration LLC & Allies Partnership
Allies Commercial Realty partnered with Collision Restoration LLC from the very beginning, advising on strategic site selection, lease structuring, and tenant improvement negotiations. From securing Aaron’s first location in Zionsville to negotiating his third and fourth locations simultaneously, our team has played a key role in supporting Collision Restoration LLC’s rapid expansion and long-term success.
Opportunity and Challenge
As a new business owner, Aaron needed to secure the right locations with long-term control over his properties while keeping operating costs in check. The key challenges in his expansion strategy included:
- Securing long-term leases – It was critical to negotiate five-year leases with multiple renewal options to ensure stability and flexibility.
- Aggressive rental schedules – Each lease needed to be structured with financially viable rental rates to align with business profitability.
- Tenant improvement allowances – The buildings required turnkey improvements such as updated office spaces, upgraded lighting, and electrical enhancements to support the needs of a modern collision repair business.
- Scalability for future growth – With a vision for five to six locations, it was essential to develop a repeatable leasing strategy that could be replicated across multiple locations while ensuring consistent deal terms.
DEAL HIGHLIGHTS
Secured a long term lease with fixed renewal options across the portfolio.
Negotiated turn-key tenant improvement package across all locations.
Analysis
We conducted a comprehensive market analysis to identify properties that met Collision Restoration LLC’s operational needs while securing favorable lease terms for each location. Ensuring fixed rental escalations and strong tenant improvement packages was a priority, allowing Aaron to scale efficiently while maintaining control over his growing portfolio.
Meet the Brokers Behind this Success Story
Our Success Story
Initial Location
- First Location – 5002 West 106th Street, Zionsville, IN (16,050 SF)
- In 2022, we secured Aaron’s first location in Zionsville.
- Negotiated a long-term lease with renewal options to ensure stability.
- Structured an aggressive rental schedule to support business profitability.
- Following the opening of this location, business took off, positioning Aaron for expansion.
Location 1 - Zionsville

5002 West 106th Street, Zionsville, IN (16,050 SF)
Expansion into Noblesville
- Second Location – 15241 Stony Creek Way, Noblesville, IN (17,862 SF)
- In early 2024, Allies Commercial Realty secured Aaron’s second location in Noblesville.
- Within six months of opening, the location saw significant growth, reinforcing the need for further expansion.
Location 2 - Noblesville

15241 Stony Creek Way, Noblesville, IN (17,862 SF)
Simultaneous Third & Fourth Locations – Greenfield & Pendleton
- Third Location – 2000 Royal Drive, Greenfield, IN (20,000 SF)
- Fourth Location – 8282 South State Road 67, Pendleton, IN (20,703 SF)
- In late 2024, Aaron engaged our team to secure both locations at the same time.
- Ensured consistent lease terms across all locations, including:
- Long-term leases with multiple renewal options.
- Fixed rental escalations for cost predictability.
- Strong tenant improvement packages for modern, fully operational facilities.
Location 3 - Greenfield

2000 Royal Drive, Greenfield, IN (20,000 SF)
Location 4 - Pendleton

8282 South State Road 67, Pendleton, IN (20,703 SF)
Results
- Scalable Lease Strategy: Secured long-term control over each property with flexible renewal options.
- Financially Strategic Deals: Negotiated aggressive rental schedules to support profitability.
- Turnkey Improvements: Ensured high-quality, functional spaces across all locations.
- Rapid Growth & Market Expansion: Enabled Collision Restoration LLC to expand from one location to four in just two years.
Conclusion
Allies Commercial Realty’s strategic market insight, lease negotiation expertise, and commitment to long-term client success have positioned Collision Restoration LLC for continued growth. As Aaron continues to expand his business, we remain actively engaged in securing additional locations to support his vision of five to six locations across Central Indiana.
Ready to Write Your Own Success Story?
Let’s explore how we can help you achieve your commercial real estate goals.
Collision Restoration LLC: Strategic Expansion & Market Growth
In Other Case Studies
Tubelite: Effective Tenant Representation for Lease Renewal in Indianapolis
Tubelite, leasing a 19,200 SF office-warehouse space in Park 100, Indianapolis, faced the challenge of renewing their lease amid a global pandemic.
Read MoreCTG International: Successful Tenant Representation for Relocation in Indianapolis
CTG International (North America) Inc. faced a significant challenge with their 32,000 SF warehouse space in Park 100, Indianapolis, IN.
Read MoreARISE Substance Abuse Care Services: Overcoming Unique Zoning Challenges to Secure the Ideal Treatment Facility
ARISE Substance Abuse Care Services, LLC was established in 2023 in Central Indiana.
Read More